Expression 1 — transitions and rhetorical synthesis

Twelve questions in the two shapes this domain uses — and it is the domain most students arrive at having never practised, because nothing in ordinary schoolwork looks like either of them.

Seven transitions. A blank between two sentences and four connectives. The question is about one thing only: the logical relationship between what comes before and what comes after. Does the second sentence follow from the first, contradict it, illustrate it, add to it, or specify it?

The method that makes these nearly mechanical is to name the relationship in your own words before reading any option, then find the family that matches. Connectives come in families:

  • cause and effect — therefore, consequently, thus, as a result
  • contrast — however, nevertheless, by contrast, on the other hand
  • addition — furthermore, in addition, moreover
  • example — for instance, for example
  • specification — specifically, in particular
  • comparison — similarly, likewise

Almost every wrong answer is a connective from the wrong family, and one of them is usually from the contrast family, because however sounds acceptable almost anywhere. If you have named the relationship first, that trap does not work; if you have not, it works nearly every time.

Five on rhetorical synthesis. You get a student's research notes as bullet points and a stated goal — emphasise a difference between the two artists, introduce this telescope to an audience unfamiliar with its design, explain why Petra succeeded as a trading centre — and four sentences to choose from.

Here is the thing that makes this question type hard and the thing that makes it easy, and they are the same thing: all four options are true. Every one of them is accurately drawn from the notes. Three of them simply do not do the job the goal describes. A sentence that reports both artists' work faithfully without setting them against each other has not emphasised a difference, however well written it is. A sentence dense with technical specification has not introduced anything to an unfamiliar audience.

So the order you read in decides the question. Goal first, then the notes, then the options. The notes always contain more than any one answer needs, and the surplus exists to furnish the wrong choices with real substance. Read the goal first and most of that surplus becomes visibly irrelevant; read the notes first and all four answers look equally well supported, which they are.

Then one test on every option: does this do the stated job? Not "is it true" and not "is it well written" — true and well written describes all four.

Twelve flashcards carry the connective families and the goal-first procedure, which between them are most of what this domain asks you to know.

  • Name the logical relationship between two sentences before looking at any connective
  • Sort transitions into families — cause, contrast, addition, example, specification, comparison — and choose by family
  • Resist "however", which sounds acceptable almost anywhere and is usually the trap
  • Read a rhetorical-synthesis question in the order goal, notes, options
  • Judge a synthesis choice by whether it does the stated job, not by whether it is true
  • Recognise that all four synthesis options are accurate, and that accuracy therefore decides nothing
  • Ignore the surplus information in a set of notes once the goal is known

Clara Schumann was a celebrated virtuoso who performed across Europe for six decades. Her own compositions were long treated as a footnote to her husband's. ________, scholars have begun to publish and record them. — The sentence before says her compositions were dismissed; the sentence after says they are now being performed. That is a reversal, so the connective has to come from the contrast family, and "Nevertheless" is the only one of the four that does.

Sample question

Biologists have long observed that certain deep-sea jellyfish emit light when disturbed. ________, this bioluminescence serves as a defense mechanism, startling potential predators and allowing the jellyfish to escape into the darkness.

See the answer

Specifically

The relationship is one of clarification or specification, as the second sentence explains the function of the phenomenon mentioned in the first. 'Specifically' is the correct choice. 'However' and 'Nevertheless' are contrast transitions, and 'By contrast' is also a contrast transition.

Try this quiz →

← Expression of Ideas

↑ SAT